Try the political quiz
+

9 Replies

 @7LQ863BRight-Wing Populism from Washington  commented…1yr1Y

Trump is correct. Birthright citizenship was never meant for the children of illegal aliens…

The child of a foreign diplomat, who is in this country *legally*, doesn’t even get it.

 @BoarsTommyConstitution from Nevada  commented…1yr1Y

Well, doesn’t the fact that it written “before our current, globally connected world” mean that all Amendments can be up for the chopping block? If the 14th “needs to end”, wouldn’t that mean especially the earlier ones like….I don’t know….the 2nd would “need to end”?

 @7LQ863BIndependent from Washington  disagreed…1yr1Y

The 14th amendment doesn’t need to be removed in order to end birthright citizenship being conferred upon illegal aliens. The 14th amendment doesn’t apply to those in our country illegally and not subject to the political jurisdiction of the United States.

 @MAGA_Deplorable from Washington  agreed…1yr1Y

Yes, but the 14th Amendment has been misinterpreted so often that it should still be removed

 @P0llingPlaceTonyVeteran from South Carolina  disagreed…1yr1Y

Anyone in the United States who doesn’t have diplomatic immunity is subject to the jurisdiction and laws on the United States. So your argument has zero merit.

 @82X57B9Anti-Immigration from Massachusetts  commented…1yr1Y

If you enter the US legally as a diplomat, tourist or with a work or student visa, a child born to you while here is not granted citizenship.

Why would we grant citizenship to children born to those who enter illegally? It makes no sense to reward illegal behavior.

 @S3nateBenForward from Kentucky  disagreed…1yr1Y

Because foreign diplomats are subject to another another country's jurisdiction. This is literally spelling out and explained in SCOTUS rulings, which also confirm that any child born in the US to illegal immigrants is, in fact, a US citizen.

 @82X57B9 from Massachusetts  disagreed…1yr1Y

Any non-citizen who enters another country illegally is also subject to their own country’s jurisdiction.

When the 14th amendment was passed, it didn’t even apply to American Indians.

The amendment was passed to give former slaves American citizenship.

 @MAGA_Deplorable from Washington  commented…1yr1Y

About this author

Learn more about the author that submitted this general discussion.

Last activeActivity8 discussionsInfluence1 engagementsEngagement bias55%Audience bias100%Active inPartyUndeclaredLocationUnknown