Try the political quiz
+

10 Replies

 @GeckoEvaRepublican from New Hampshire  commented…1yr1Y

Look at the numbers - Iranian exports went from 3M to 420K bpd under the first max pressure campaign. But they bounced back to 1.8M now. Sanctions alone clearly aren't enough without diplomatic engagement.

 @MackerelZachConstitutionfrom Georgia  disagreed…1yr1Y

Actually, the real story here is the Chabahar port angle. Rescinding those waivers could seriously complicate India's strategic position in the region. Not seeing enough discussion of this tbh

 @AnxiousE1ectionAmerican Solidarityfrom New Jersey  commented…1yr1Y

So first it was "blow Iran to smithereens" and now it's "peaceful nuclear agreement"?? Make it make sense 🙄 At least the maximum pressure sanctions worked before!

 @Lobby1stDanLibertarian from Oregon  disagreed…1yr1Y

The data doesn't support that sanctions "worked" - they just shifted trade to less transparent channels. Oil exports never actually stopped, they just went underground.

 @8GFJ74BAnti-Globalization from Michigan  commented…1yr1Y

Speaking as someone who's worked in nuclear nonproliferation - verified agreements ARE possible. Iran has consistently said they're open to discussions about weapons-grade enrichment limits. The missile program is the real sticking point.

 @883RXKWRealism from Tennessee  agreed…1yr1Y

💯 on the missile point. Iran sees that program as existential given their conventional military limitations. No way they'll include it in any nuclear deal - that's a non-starter

 @95H9FMDIslamic Modernism from Pennsylvania  commented…1yr1Y

Important context: China's refining changes are about domestic efficiency, not Iran compliance. They're still taking 1.7M of 1.8M total Iranian export barrels daily. Let's not overstate their willingness to cut imports.

 @PorpoiseZoeEconomic Democracy from New Hampshire  commented…1yr1Y

Key point everyone's missing: China might actually play ball this time. They're already planning to restructure their refining sector and shut down the "teapot" refineries that process most Iranian crude. Different incentives now.

 @CrowCarolineSocialistfrom Maine  commented…1yr1Y

These policies have real human costs on both sides. The Iranian people suffer under sanctions while American consumers face higher gas prices. There has to be a better way forward than this endless cycle 💔

 @8SCTGQZDirect Democracy from Texas  commented…1yr1Y

This is why markets barely moved. You can't just "drive exports to zero" when there's a massive shadow fleet already operating outside western financial systems. China's still buying 1.7M bpd right now.

Demographics

Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion

Loading data...