Try the political quiz
+

17 Replies

 @GallantMandateGreenfrom New York  commented…2yrs2Y

So they were blocking aid…

 @Vot3rVo1ceBitternSocialist from Pennsylvania  agreed…2yrs2Y

Yeah, we knew they were lying. Now we're supposed to thank them for stopping doing that thing they said they weren't doing (they were lying when they said that) (we knew).

 @WearyInd3p3ndentRepublican from California  disagreed…2yrs2Y

They weren't, Erez Crossing was a movement crossing and not a goods crossing. Palestinians destroyed it on 07/10 after the UN and EU pulled millions into its renovations and expansions. Biden literally asks here Israel to convert it to a goods crossing.

 @AffectedHouseRepublicanfrom Washington  commented…2yrs2Y

One of the (many) ironies is that the same international actors (including the U.S.) who claim to be so interested in the welfare of civilians in Rafah have done NOTHING in terms of offering assistance to provide infrastructure for relocation elsewhere in Gaza. On the contrary, most insist that nothing can be done, all the while congratulating themselves for keeping Israel boxed in (“Oh, how clever we are”).

 @SerenePragmaticSocialist from Oregon  disagreed…2yrs2Y

1/ since 🇮🇱 has control over most of the Gaza Strip, relocation within Gaza is in fact entirely at Israel’s discretion and cannot be randomly done by some international actor.

2/ It’s been a matter of record for some time now that 🇮🇱 will control movement back to North Gaza.

There is zero inherent need for countries to be giving help to Israel unless they really get something tangible. Otherwise they will look like subcontractors and financiers of occupation. With zero evidence that Israel seeks a realistic day after plan or a 2SS, this is a dead end

 @AffectedHouseRepublicanfrom Washington  disagreed…2yrs2Y

Of course there needs to be a day-after plan, but the idea that helping to provide in-country but safer refuge for civilians is a negative is not found in other conflicts. It’s more the unspoken “but if civilians are relocated Hamas will be defeated” that’s at play. Just like the unspoken “how can you expect Hamas to release hostages and lose its leverage?”

 @AffectedHouseRepublicanfrom Washington  disagreed…2yrs2Y

The 4th Geneva Convention imposes obligations on Hamas. Like keeping civilians away from military operations & vice versa. And the concept of “occupying power” is way more complex than you’d like to believe. Israel indeed has serious obligations, but not as you describe them.

 @OptimisticRaisinsGreen from Texas  disagreed…2yrs2Y

Are you kidding i hope? Israel is the occupying power he has the duty of safety of the civilians. they chose to act differently now dont cry. war is lost.

 @Gr4ssrootsRonnieGreen from Virginia  commented…2yrs2Y

Weird how Biden’s calls with Netanyahu keep getting more tense but somehow never enough to suspend even one weapon sale

 @EmptyP0llingPlaceSocialist from Minnesota  agreed…2yrs2Y

That happens when you end your calls with, "How can I stay mad at you? I can't, that's how. Talk soon, clicking send on that transfer now."

 @CheerfulSwiftRepublicanfrom Kentucky  commented…2yrs2Y

here are few questions i have

1. how will idf secure the aid so hamas doesn’t steal it?

2. is there any concern about rockets falling on ashdod airport?

 @ElectoralTacosGreenfrom Maryland  commented…2yrs2Y

Answer to (1) is that Israel has done a pretty good job picking off Hamas operatives in charge of stealing and selling aid. They can continue doing that.

 @ISIDEWITHasked…2yrs2Y

How do you feel about a government making rapid policy changes in response to international pressure?

 @ISIDEWITHasked…2yrs2Y

How important do you believe it is for countries to work together to ensure the safe delivery of aid to those in need?

 @ISIDEWITHasked…2yrs2Y

Is it ever justifiable for another country to influence the domestic policies of another nation?

 @ISIDEWITHasked…2yrs2Y

What impact do you think opening the Erez crossing for aid will have on the everyday lives of civilians?

 @ISIDEWITHasked…2yrs2Y

Should military leaders be held accountable and face consequences for their actions in conflict situations?

Demographics

Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion

Loading data...