In 1993 the federal government passed the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act. The law was intended to protect Native Americans in danger of losing their jobs because of religious ceremonies that involved the illegal drug peyote. In 1997 the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that Congress overstepped its bounds in passing RFRA in 1993, and that the law applied only to federal laws, not to those passed by the states. Since then 22 U.S. states have passed their own versions of the “religious freedom” laws. Supporters of the law argue that the government shouldn’t force religiou…
Read moreNarrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
@B3PH3FZ2mos2MO
A business should have the freedom to operate based on its values, but not in a way that promotes discrimination. While owners have the right to their beliefs, service should be provided fairly and within legal and respectful boundaries
@B2KW47V 4mos4MO
It depends on the extent of the service. Baking a cake and having someone pick it up at the store is okay to not allow the denial of, but requiring someone to attend a gay wedding is unacceptable.
@B24MB9Y5mos5MO
A business should be allowed to deny service when it does not depend on a customer's life or health.
@9W6DSRK7mos7MO
It would depend on the business, the product being sold etc. In some instances yes, but most instances probably not.
Only if the request would cause the business personnel to directly perform an action that goes against their religion, not if the actions are being performed by the customers and the business is trying to force it's personnel's religious behavior or to show disapproval of the actions of the customers.
@9TFHWBH8mos8MO
Yes, if the customer is being blatantly disrespectful towards the owner or the employees they should be able to get kid out.
@9MT2F8412mos12MO
Yes, but only if this denial is nondiscriminatory (for example, a Muslim deli owner refusing to use bacon on sandwiches)
I think you should only be able to refuse service to someone if they want you to make/ provide something hateful (nazi flag on a cake, racist t-shirt idk)
@9GFPNJB2yrs2Y
Yes but only if the business or service being provided to said person would directly go against their express religious beliefs
@9GFK7KH2yrs2Y
There should not be discrimination in terms of service, but if the owner happens to be Muslim or another region and doesn’t want to serve a cake to a homosexual couple, he has the right to not take part in that. My only concern would be that people would use those rules as loopholes for other forms of discrimination, which is obviously not ideal.
@9FY2RCF2yrs2Y
Yes, but the business owner should be required to refer the customer to a business who provides this service.
@9WVG8RD7mos7MO
I believe everyone should be treated equally, however small businesses could hold the right to refuse certain beliefs to an extent, overall it shouldn't necessarily be allowed.
@96DN8B73yrs3Y
depends on the circumstance and belief
@96DLLXP3yrs3Y
It depends on what they are denying it based off. If it’s something the customer cannot control then they shouldn’t deny
@93L6QTS3yrs3Y
I don’t really care there’s always another business
@93774VD3yrs3Y
If it is discriminatory then they should not be allowed to deny people. But if somebody is discriminating against a company's workers than the worker should be allowed to deny the customer
@92WMQNQ3yrs3Y
Religious beliefs should be separated from business decisions
@92M6HFP3yrs3Y
No, because doing so is bad business. If one’s beliefs are so strong as to discriminate against other, perhaps one shouldn’t operate a business.
@8WXQ9ZF4yrs4Y
Most businesses have a business statement that states “we reserve the right to not serve/refuse service” and they have the right just like anyone else has their rights to not serve - but not other than religious beliefs- just as someone can choose not to patronize a business because of what they don’t believe or want to purchase from a business
@8VB8HVQ4yrs4Y
Yes, so long as the customer is not being discriminated
@8TF8HXXRepublican4yrs4Y
Yes it is a business’s first amendment right to practice religion
@8RBLT264yrs4Y
thats the owners decision
@8QY2YMXRepublican4yrs4Y
Yes, only because it's the owner's establishment. They have the final say in what they do woth their business
@8NCKQS25yrs5Y
No. Church and state are intended to be separate and that should apply to business as well. Religious beliefs are personal and private while a business is public. Refusing service on the basis of religious beliefs is no different than attempting to force your belief systems on another person.
@dwlongton965yrs5Y
Yes, but to a point. Businesses should treat all customers equally; however, if the beliefs are known to be controversial to policies for the business, then the business has the right to turn down a customer, but must come from an anti-discriminatory approach.
@8LRG5YM5yrs5Y
i dont see how that could be possible
@8KLQL955yrs5Y
Money is money. Either you take it or you don’t.
@8KHC5NH5yrs5Y
Yes, but only if the service or the event for which the service is being provided violates their beliefs, not based on who the person is.
@8KGJ44Q5yrs5Y
a "private" business that does specialized, contracted work should be able to do so. Never on a day to day commerce. A warning of possible denial stating what the business beliefs and what they refuse should be given.
@8JYW44N5yrs5Y
This question is way to broad. A business owner should be able to deny an extremist religious terrorist a drink at the bar. However, they should not be able to deny someone simply because they’re Jewish, Christian, etc...
@8J5GFDK5yrs5Y
Yes, if the service is relevant to the owner's beliefs
@8J2Y8HT5yrs5Y
Yes, but only if the request requires the business person to perform an action contrary to their religion. Not solely because they disagree with the lifestyle of the person they are asked to serve.
@8HCJGLJ5yrs5Y
Yes, it is the companies choice of how they treat their customers
@8G5DC7K5yrs5Y
Yes, but only for small, private companies and it should be done in a respectful manner.
@8F3DYHW5yrs5Y
Yes but only if there are competitors if the same business within a reasonable area
@8DN4HHZ5yrs5Y
Private companies, it's their own funeral...
@8CXMN3Z5yrs5Y
Yes people should be able to tell others about their religious beliefs and follow them.
@9CL8ZY3Libertarian2yrs2Y
Yes, although all customers deserve to be treated with equity.
@9CJ5C6J2yrs2Y
Yes, but only if the request itself directly goes against their religious beliefs or practices.
@9CDYM87Libertarian2yrs2Y
Yes, provided they give a list of alternative local choices.
@9BGJYQY2yrs2Y
Yes, but the business must make an adequate effort to provide an alternative service
@9B6CQ682yrs2Y
Yes, but only for private or small businesses
@9B4RRW7Republican2yrs2Y
Yes, for a business where the request for certain artistic services violates the owners religious beliefs such a request decorate a Satan themed cake.
@999CP642yrs2Y
it depends like are they homophobic and/or racist? then it's ok. if theyre just homosexual and/or poc then f that
@99752LS2yrs2Y
Yes, but only private businesses should have this ability.
@97LZYGH3yrs3Y
yes, but the owner should try to post something to let customers know what is restricted/refused
@97LKGZH3yrs3Y
They have every right to do so, but if it's a small community with few options they are being petty and should not be lauded for it.
@97D5FY53yrs3Y
No, but owner's should still have a right to religious freedom and only make exceptions related to customer assistance
@Dmiyagi3yrs3Y
Yes, unless that request involves simply denying service because the costumer is a member of a protected class
@87V5TYYRepublican4yrs4Y
No, if a customer’s request is not a threat to human life or the business owner themselves, it is not right to discriminate
@8PXVMHR4yrs4Y
No, if the request is not a threat to human life or their business it isn’t right to discriminate
@8QR8W784yrs4Y
@8H2544S5yrs5Y
Only because this is their religion
@8JZZ99T5yrs5Y
Yes, but only in the sense of their Constitutional right to freedom of religion. As in Masterpiece cake shop v. Colorado Civil Rights.
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.