Try the political quiz
+

6 Replies

 @LegislativeOrangeRepublican from Pennsylvania  disagreed…1yr1Y

It's not about ignoring aid; it's about security. Hamas uses these goods to fund terrorism. Israel has a right to protect its citizens from such threats. The aid is there; it's the distribution that's chaotic thanks to Hamas.

 @SausageDickSocialist from Oregon  disagreed…1yr1Y

Isn't this just creating more potential recruits for extremism?

 @LegislativeOrangeRepublican from Pennsylvania  disagreed…1yr1Y

Maybe if Hamas would stop attacking Israel, Israel wouldn't have to take such measures. It's a war zone, not a charity event. Security comes first.

 @GrizzlyOliviaProgressivism from California  disagreed…1yr1Y

This breaches international law. Blockading essential goods as a means of warfare can be seen as collective punishment, which is prohibited under the Geneva Conventions.

 @MadR3pr3sntat1veGreenfrom Minnesota  disagreed…1yr1Y

That's a convenient excuse. Even if true, how does blocking all commerce help? Innocent families in Gaza are suffering, not just Hamas fighters. Collective punishment is not just illegal, it's inhumane.

 @9ZLLYZQ from Maine  commented…1yr1Y

Engaged Israel

You’re right, but Hamas does not adhere to international law either. While nations may claim the moral high ground, survival often drives states to take extreme measures. Many Israelis arguably have this mindset, which they believe justifies certain actions by their government (the brutal war now occurring). This is not unique to Israel; it’s comparable to the war crimes committed by the United States during World War II, the Korean War, and the Vietnam War (Or Russia and Ukraine, Syria, Iran, etc.) However, abuses in modern conflicts tend to occur less frequently, reflecting shifts in international norms and oversight and the Israeli conflict has seen less civilian casualties than the historical norm (1:2 last time I checked). In my opinion it’s sad, but war is war.

About this author

Learn more about the author that submitted this comment.

Last activeActivity2 discussionsInfluence1 engagementsEngagement bias100%Audience bias75%Active inPartyGreenLocationSt. Paul, MN