See More Questions Answer This
News  |  Quiz  |  Polls  |  Your Results

Question

Should law enforcement be allowed to detain illegal immigrants for minor crimes so that federal immigration authorities can take custody of them?

Answer | Learn more | Share

Results

Last answered 32secs ago

Illegal Immigrant Detainment Poll Results

Yes

605,539 votes

62%

No

374,536 votes

38%

Distribution of answers submitted by America.

2 Yes answers
3 No answers
0 overlapping answers

Data includes total votes submitted by visitors since Oct 8, 2013. For users that answer more than once (yes we know), only their most recent answer is counted in the total results. Total percentages may not add up to exactly 100% as we allow users to submit "grey area" stances that may not be categorized into yes/no stances.

Choose a demographic filter

* Data estimated by matching users to U.S. Census data block groups via the American Community Survey (2007-2011)

Yes No Importance

See more illegal immigration news

Data based on 30-day moving average to reduce daily variance from traffic sources. Totals may not add up to exactly 100% as we allow users to submit "grey area" stances that may not be categorized into yes/no stances.

Data based on 30-day moving average to reduce daily variance from traffic sources. Totals may not add up to exactly 100% as we allow users to submit "grey area" stances that may not be categorized into yes/no stances.

Learn more about Illegal Immigrant Detainment

On October 7, 2013 California Governor Jerry Brown signed a state bill prohibiting law-enforcement officials from detaining an individual on the basis of a U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement hold after that person becomes eligible for release, unless he or she has been charged with or convicted of certain crimes, including violent felonies.  See recent illegal immigration news

More stances on this issue

If they have committed a crime (violent or not) and are illegal immigrants they need to be deported. 8mons ago from a Republican in Potwin, KS.

Yes, illegal aliens should be detained and returned to their home country without any delay, no court hearing, none of that stuff that delays the return to home country. Right now an illegal & US ICE are playing a cat and mouse game. The illegal has to be caught 30 times before he/she is deported. That is ridiculous. After all, I can't sneak across the Mexican border or I will go to jail. Same with any other country. We are the only goofballs that let them stay and stay and stay and wring our hands about what to do about them. Every day criminals and pedophiles cross our border to do harm to our citizens. 8mons ago from a Republican in Bellaire, TX.

Yes, they should be detained so that they may be deported by the state. The federal government has already demonstrated a lifetime ineptitude with regard to immigration policy. 7mons ago from a Republican in Beaverton, OR.

Obey current law and then send "bill" for deportation and room and board while in U.S. custody to the country where they came from .. and expect payment. 7mons ago from a Republican in Denver, CO.

Yes in fact all law enforcement in the course of doing their jobs should be charged with the task of asking if a suspected person of all types is a citizen. We all have drivers licenses and ID for cashing checks, ETC in this society. Should be for voting too. I would proudly show mine but we have to be careful of how we treat those off the grid but even they have a story that can be checked out. We can't just stop peoples free travel on fishing trips of citizenship tho. 7mons ago from a Republican in Rutland, VT.

Those who come here from any other country and willing to become US citizens, learn English and follow our laws are welcome. If not and you break laws...you have to go back. 7mons ago from a Republican in Clearview City, KS.

Technically, they're illegal and should not be in the country. However, I think that if they are paying taxes and working and are not causing violent crimes or any trouble, they should be allowed to stay and work to gain a visa and/or American citizenship. 7mons ago from a Democrat in Duncanville, TX.

I have no real issue with illegal immigrants as long as they are non-violent and no drug association. so, if they suspected of crimes from their homeland, then i have no problem with them being tatrgeted. 7mons ago from a Green in Jenks, OK.

Provide a path for those here and control the border. All Americans should have I.D. cards. All those without US I.D. or current legal Passport need to be deported. 7mons ago from a Republican in Potwin, KS.

Crime prevention starts at the basic street level. If an area has a large immigrant population from countries known for corruption, lack of crimes are a huge issue. Years of police community outreach programs would be destroyed while opening another crack for terrorist or crime gangs to exploit. 7mons ago from a Democrat in Carrollton, MI.

A crime committed by an illegal immigrant should result in deportation, just as our neighboring countries do. Deportation should be paid for by the criminal, if possible. 7mons ago from a Democrat in Pacifica, CA.

First this should be handled like any individual who has allegedly committed a crime. If found to be an illegal immigrant then legislation in place would indicate the legality of any and all procedures. 7mons ago from a Democrat in Milan, TN.

Mexican illegals should be granted citizen ship without question immediately and given a handshake... we welcome terrorists into the country and give them tax breaks every day, we should extend the same privilige we had when we stole this country from the natives to our neighbors to the south. 7mons ago from a Democrat in Lakewood, OH.

Federal immigration authorities want to use them as pawns for Democrat Party. They pick and choose which laws to enforce for personal gain. 7mons ago from a Republican in Tucson, AZ.

Yes, all illegal immigrants should be turned over to federal authorities prosecuted sent to prison at hard labor then deported after completing their entire sentence. 7mons ago from a Libertarian in Middle Island, NY.

We must define what constitutes a minor crime. For minor offenses (such as traffic laws) individual should face local laws like anyone else, but not fear to be deported. 7mons ago from a Republican in Middletown, CT.

A minor crime is still a crime. This has nothing to do with immigrant issues. 7mons ago from a Democrat in La Jolla, CA.

NO CHINA RULES GG. 7mons ago from a Democrat in Fontana, CA.

Illegal immigrants should be either deported or forced to become english-speaking, tax-paying citizens if they want to stay here. These persons should lose their citizenship and deported following serious crimes, including membership in violent gangs. 7mons ago from a Democrat in Bayville, NJ.

Take them in and let them take the appropriate steps to become a citizen, if they chose not to send them back home, we can not afford to keep taking care of them and allowing them the benefits which should go to the born and raised us citizen. US Citizens are not getting a fair deal, to much is offered to people coming into this country and the Americans are feeling the pain of this. Charity begins are home, you cant help others of you are not able to help yourself!. 7mons ago from a Democrat in Union City, NJ.

Determination of status dependent on suitability for citizenship ex: are they violent, pattern of multiple offences, etc. should be criteria for deportation. Under 10 yrs old or born in US - no unless there is no family that will take responsibility for them here. 7mons ago from a Democrat in Brisbane, CA.

They should be immediately sent back to where they came from. there is a legal method of entering other countries they should use it. 7mons ago from a Republican in Andrews, TX.

No. They should be subjected to the same penalties as citizens for violent crimes followed by deportation. Non-violent offenders should be deported. 7mons ago from a Libertarian in Barium Springs, NC.

Deport for violent crime, as well DUI or any crime against person or property. 7mons ago from a Republican in Russellville, AR.

Only if the federal government pays for that incarseration. Immigration is the exclusive purview of the federal government per the US Consitution. States and local municipalites need not play. 7mons ago from a Democrat in Montgomery, AL.

Minor crimes is subjective. there should be a fast track for citizenship. if the crime is harmful to the state or country or community they should be removed. drug dealers, hit and runs, DUI, person to person crimes. 7mons ago from a Green in Eugene, OR.

Yes but I mean to say: if we tax paying citizens are detained for minor crimes, then the same should be the case for illegal immigrants. 7mons ago from a Republican in Jersey City, NJ.

Illegal immigrants should be aware that remaining in US soil is an opportunity to create a better life for themselves and their families. Immigrants who violate the law and have been charged with a crime should be tried fairly and if found guilty of violent crimes, should be deported. Immigrants who have proven their innocence and are elegible for release, should NOT, by any means be detained by any branch of law enforcement. 7mons ago from a Republican in Nashville, TN.

If illegal immigrants are found breaking minor laws they should be deported. If they are guilty of a felony or a more serious crime they should be tried and convicted. Once their time has been served they should be deported. 7mons ago from a Republican in Lynchburg, VA.

No. This should not be a priority for local law enforcement. 7mons ago from a Republican in Medina, WA.

Discuss this issue...