Should the US increase or decrease the amount of temporary work visas given to high-skilled immigrant workers?
Skilled temporary work visas are usually given to foreign scientists, engineers, programmers, architects, executives, and other positions or fields where demand outpaces supply. Most businesses argue that hiring skilled foreign workers allows them to competitively fill positions which are in high demand. Opponents argue that skilled immigrants decrease middle class wages and job tenure.
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Discussions from these authors are shown:
@B458PS2Independent2mos2MO
Increase temporary work visas given, but increase wages to provide incentives for citizens to also work those jobs and be able to make a living off of them
@B3B8VRF2mos2MO
I think we should give out as many as there are people applying, good at what they do, and of course willing to work, however I do think the government should monitor this in case of companies taking advantage of foreigners and giving them decreased wages.
@9WK5W3V7mos7MO
We need to increase the number of work visas but make sure they only are given to legal, non-violet immigrants.
@9VPVDF27mos7MO
Maintain it whatever level it needs to be to ensure we have the people we need in which to function.
@9MS62CQLibertarian12mos12MO
Everyone has opportunities to gain the skills for these jobs & should be paid fairly. Whomever is best skilled should get the job, legally, paying taxes & paid fairly. (Assuming this higher education in the US gets sorted out)
@9JY7R3R1yr1Y
deberian de aumentar la cantidad de visas otorgadas a trabajadores de distintos paise pero ofrecerles un mejor salario o igualarlo al salario de los residentes ya que ellos hacen el mismo trabajo que un residente
@9JRHYDRProgressive1yr1Y
Work visas should be severely decreased, as companies are taking advantage to decrease wages of our citizens and because every year there continues to be an increase in people overstaying works and school visas.
Increase, businesses need to expediently hire high skilled workers to fill job positions where demand outpaces supply
@9FZPSHS 2yrs2Y
Increase - temporary work visas allow us to attract the best and brightest workers in many cases, giving us a competitive edge
Increase, hiring skilled foreign workers allows businesses to fill positions where demand outpaces supply
Increase, our economy depends on hiring the highest skilled workers for positions where demand outpaces supply
@95T982XProgressive3yrs3Y
We should encourage and provide our own citizens with incentives for these jobs, but also grant work-visas when needed, although highly regulate so companies do not take advantage of this system.
Increase, but require their employer to pay them the same or more than local workers
@93NMKHM3yrs3Y
Increase or decrease- neither matters if the companies hiring them aren’t forced to pay living wages.
@8Z784YPIndependent3yrs3Y
This should probably be determined by industry and the needs of the market, not by politics.
Increase, but ensure local and government regulation on companies in order to prevent them from taking advantage of these workers and lowering wages
@8XNBCSY3yrs3Y
If they come from China, a communist country like China no; too many are members of the CCP. Other foreigners who hail from other communist or terrorist countries should have a rigorous screening process to check if they are spies or terrorists. Anyone who is found smuggling fentanyl or humans needs to be deported immediately. They should not be taking jobs from US citizens just because they are willing to take lower wages; only if there is a shortage of qualified people in the said field.
I think it should be increased only if they are going to also pay them more money
@8VCFHWJ4yrs4Y
Increase, with fewer loopholes for larger corporations to circumvent the “high-skilled” definition
Increase, but improve programs for our citizens
@8SBVG6T4yrs4Y
Decrease, and give them a path to citizenship
@8RQK9RH4yrs4Y
Increase, and allow for them to receive higher wages, equal to those of U.S. citizens
@8QJHP5TRepublican4yrs4Y
For as many work visas as we need.
@8PKN4F2Republican4yrs4Y
It depends on the needs of American citizens. Increase if job opportunities are plentiful. Decrease if a recession is occurring.
@8NGPLW85yrs5Y
Increase, but post and set standard wages so there is no incentive to hire immigrants other than skill
@8MBRHP25yrs5Y
Increase but develop better tracking for expired documentation
@8M9WC2P5yrs5Y
Increase, but standardize wages so the only incentive is having the most skilled workers
@8LKKVJZRepublican5yrs5Y
Increase if there’s people willing to work and are qualified
@8L6VX5N5yrs5Y
I am unsure of my stance.
@8KM9BXQ5yrs5Y
Maintain, however we should looking more into partnering with the countries who's citizens help uplift our own countries economy.
@8HSZH545yrs5Y
There should be no limits to these visas. If the person is qualified, it is the right of the company to hire them and allow them to come to the US to serve provided they pass immigration application and background check/screening processes.
@8HH7HC95yrs5Y
I say decrease, because Americans need to have jobs. I know most are looking for a better life, but as we are seeing immigrant children coming here with family, some of the immigrate children have grown up and now taking over our Government and bring their radical ideas to America. It must be stopped!
@8GHY56K5yrs5Y
Yes, and those workers should be paid according to no -immigrant pay scale standards.
@8CSDBJBWomen’s Equality5yrs5Y
Decrease but increase policies to include these individuals in minimum wage laws
@99ZTCNWRepublican2yrs2Y
Decrease. I think we are draining other nations of skilled professionals.
@99G3SFP2yrs2Y
Decrease drastically and severely limit the reasons they might be granted.
Increase, but the government should be providing more incentives to prepare our citizens for these jobs
I am satisfied with the current amount, but increase incentives to prepare our citizens for these jobs
@8TFP2BC4yrs4Y
Decrease, companies are currently taking advantage of this program to decrease wages and we have a duty to our OWN citizens to get them working.
I am satisfied with the current amount, but make it easier for immigrants to obtain these temporary work visas
Increase, and the government should also provide more incentives to prepare our citizens for these jobs
Decrease, we should prioritize offering these jobs to qualified domestic workers and utilize skilled immigrant workers only when demand exceeds our available supply
I am satisfied with the current amount, but sponsor and increase skilled corporate training programs so domestic workers may successfully compete for these positions
Decrease, we should prioritize offering these jobs to qualified domestic workers and utilize skilled immigrant workers only when demand exceeds our available supply.
Increase at this current point in time, but the government should provide more incentives to prepare our citizens for these jobs
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.