See More Questions Answer This
News  |  Quiz  |  Polls  |  Your Results

Question

Should children of illegal immigrants be granted citizenship?

Answer | Share

Results

Last answered 19secs ago

Immigration Poll Results

Yes

5,871,106 votes

60%

No

3,964,333 votes

40%

Distribution of answers submitted by America.

6 Yes answers
2 No answers
0 overlapping answers

Data includes total votes submitted by visitors since Dec 12, 2011. For users that answer more than once (yes we know), only their most recent answer is counted in the total results. Total percentages may not add up to exactly 100% as we allow users to submit "grey area" stances that may not be categorized into yes/no stances.

Choose a demographic filter

* Data estimated by matching users to U.S. Census data block groups via the American Community Survey (2007-2011)

Yes No Importance

See more immigration news

Data based on 30-day moving average to reduce daily variance from traffic sources. Totals may not add up to exactly 100% as we allow users to submit "grey area" stances that may not be categorized into yes/no stances.

Data based on 30-day moving average to reduce daily variance from traffic sources. Totals may not add up to exactly 100% as we allow users to submit "grey area" stances that may not be categorized into yes/no stances.

More stances on this issue

Depends on what they are doing with their life. Productive citizens yes, criminal no. 7mons ago from a Democrat in Gotha, FL.

When you cross into our border you are illegal and all your children born here are illegal like YOU! they should not be citizens. congress needs to change the law and do it NOW and date in back years!. 6mons ago from a Democrat in Camarillo, CA.

Yes after a few years and going through citizenship process. 7mons ago from a Democrat in Rockland, DE.

Only if they have lived in the US their entire lives and have not lived in the parent's home land. 7mons ago from a Democrat in Raritan, NJ.

If they are born here they are citizens, however their parents may be deported as they have committed a crime entering the country illegally. They may apply for citizenship once they have returned to their native country. The child may stay or go and retain citizenship. 6mons ago from a Republican in Dayton, OH.

Children should be allowed to stay with permanent visa but not be allowed citizenship nor allowed to vote. 6mons ago from a Republican in Boca Raton, FL.

NO to citizenship, but upon review, grant visa good for 10 year to work towards citizenship. No other relatives allowed via chain migration. There again, there should be NO amnesty or anything if you have been here less than 10 years. 6mons ago from a Republican in Waterbury, CT.

If parents have found work and lived here successfully under our laws, then they should be able to apply for and given a way to become citzens. Children born here are citizens, but should be given a choice when they are 18 to return. 6mons ago from a Democrat in Harrisville, NH.

All children born here ARE U.S. citizens. All children brought here before 18 should be allowed to apply for and be fast tracked for citizenship, no military or other service required. Others with clean records should be allowed to apply. 6mons ago from a Democrat in Saint Louis, MO.

Why should the children of illegal immigrants be denied citizenship if our government was to lazy or incompetent to either keep their parents out of this country or expel them once they were here illegally. On the other hand, if the children of illegal immigrants are, themselves, criminals or some other unwanted people, they should not get the benefits of our country's freedoms. Children of illegal immigrants should be given an opportunity to gain citizenship by completing certain steps to prove their worthiness (or unworthiness) but not just be granted blanket citizenship just because they are here. 6mons ago from a Democrat in Monticello, NY.

Illegal immigrants children should be citizens of the family's origin not of where they are born. If the parents are here illegally they should not of been here to bare children. If a child is here illegally because of the parent they should be allowed to perform types of public service (military or other) to gain there citizenship,. 6mons ago from a Republican in Salt Lake City, UT.

Yes, especially after 4 years of military services and/or earning a college degree. Others should apply after they turn 18 and Congress needs to define a path for citizenship for all other illegal immigrants who come forward, obey our laws, pay taxes. etc. 6mons ago from a Democrat in Potwin, KS.

The borders need to be closed, all illegals shall be subject to fraud investigation, including identity theft. Only children born here to a father and mother shall be granted limited access to citizenship and no voting rights until they become american citizens. Paternity tests shall be made on all people who have collected any federal or state aid and back child support shall be paid before granting any citizenship access. None shall be granted immediate citizenship and none shall be give any privileges extending to other members of the family. they shall not be granted any special privileges including federal aid, housing, schooling and shall not be able to file a law suit because of past discrimination. 6mons ago from a Republican in Alameda, CA.

Children born to illegal parents should still be illegal immigrants.Born here should not make automatic legal citizens. Citizenship to illegal immagrants should be earned. 6mons ago from a Libertarian in Fort Wayne, IN.

Yes. ..but only after they graduate from High School. Since the American people paid taxes to support their education why waste that investment. 6mons ago from a Democrat in Beaufort, SC.

Yes they should have citizenship if they where born here yet they should leave with there parents if deported to not split up family and they may return if they pwant later in life. 6mons ago from a Republican in Pasco, WA.

For full uncompromised democratic rights for immigrants! Everybody who's made it here has a right to stay. 6mons ago from a Green in Saint Petersburg, FL.

Those born in the US are citizens virtue their birth, those who were brought in as children should have the option of accepting US citizenship at 18. 6mons ago from a Green in Mabelvale, AR.

Yes, children born here should be afforded the privilege of dual citizenship until age 18 with the US and their parent's COO- much like the children of American citizens who are born while their parents are abroad. 6mons ago from a Green in Rossville, GA.

In the case of Mexico where the citizens are afraid to fight for themselves to regain their own freedom. Why should we fight for them when they are unwilling to fight. Allowing the children that were born in the US to stay and become citizens is good maybe them will go back to save their people. 6mons ago from a Republican in Schaumburg, IL.

This is not a federal issue but a parental obligation. We can not curb illegal Immigration if parents are not willing to become US citizens. They owe their children that much. Once a child becomes 21 they can apply for citizenship like anyone else and let serving in the armed forces or attaining a college be contributing salient and accelerating factors to citizenship. 6mons ago from a Republican in Albuquerque, NM.

Yes and No Yes if they wish to expand and work towards a wage system that enables them to be taken off food stamps. No if they chose to rotate the family in and out of jobs in order to allow for collection of unemployment benefits. 6mons ago from a Republican in Colorado Springs, CO.

Close the borders! You can deal with a leaky boat that still has holes in it. We will NEVER solve this problem if we don't stem the influx. Right now we are still trying to assimilate the current batch of first generation immigrants that came here for a better opportunity and we poisoned them with handouts instead of work. Healthcare for all is totally impossible if all keeps growing with increasing numbers of non-contributors. 6mons ago from a Republican in Royersford, PA.

Children of illegal immigrants that were born within the U.S. should have citizenship, however, children that were not born here should be allowed the opportunity to apply for citizenship, but should adhere to the same citizenship application process as any other immigrant. 6mons ago from a Libertarian in Sullivan, WI.

If we had enforced the laws that are on the books, we would not have that problem. Given that the problem is now too large, grant those born here citizenship after going through a process proving they are loyal and are not criminals. 6mons ago from a Libertarian in Scottsbluff, NE.

It's to complicated to explain here. 6mons ago from a Democrat in Deerfield Beach, FL.

The law has been interpreted as "dry foot" means citizenship. Their parents should not be granted citizenship except through appropriate channels. The real issue is when are we going to "fix" Mexico . . . the biggest source of our Immigration problems. 6mons ago from a Republican in Vicksburg, MS.

If their living conditions in their home country were dismal, yes. As long as their life in the United States would provide them with stability and hope for life ahead. 6mons ago from a Green in Morristown, NJ.

No, but there should be a way for them to apply for a green card once they reach certain conditions. 6mons ago from a Republican in Potwin, KS.

If they are born here, yes, but their parents should not be given any kind of pass. After they turn 18, if they have been deported with their parents in order to keep the family together, then they could be allowed to come in to the country legally since they are citizens. Or they could be allowed to stay in the US with a legal resident while their illegal parents are deported. 7mons ago from a Libertarian in Roswell, GA.

Discuss this issue...