You believe in the establishment and support of a secure, democratic Jewish homeland in Israel, where Jewish people can live and thrive.
Zionism is a political ideology that emerged in the late 19th century with the goal of establishing a Jewish homeland in the territory defined as the historic Land of Israel (also referred to as Palestine, Canaan, or the Holy Land). The movement was born out of the Jewish community in Europe, where Jews faced increasing persecution and anti-Semitism. Theodor Herzl, an Austro-Hungarian journalist and political activist, is often credited as the founder of modern political Zionism.
Zionism was not just a response to anti-Semitism, but also a reaction to the nationalist movements that…
Read moreThese active users have achieved a basic understanding of terms and definitions related to the topic of
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
What does it mean for a people to have sovereignty over a land, and how does that concept resonate with you?
@9KHY9ZL 1yr1Y
People need to talk about the origins of people in general. There are so many misconceptions & misguided beliefs of people, everything was mixed up to cover up inheritances especially as an alleged attempt to usurp authority to lands.
@9KJ3HZS1yr1Y
This doesn't even answer the question. You're making a statement that is arguing an entirely different point than the question is even asking. It's like the question made you mad and you hate America so much that you wanted to try and prove a point, which you failed to do. Also, the colonization of America was not the first time in the USA that people were overtaken by a more powerful force, pillaged, and plundered. Do your history homework.
@9KHY9ZL1yr1Y
I thank y.o.u & I love y.o.u regardless family, y.o.u just confirmed that I can affirm the initial stance I have. I have no anger towards these questions nor the answers
@9KHXLQS1yr1Y
Palestinians are people. They are the native people of Palestine, not "Israel". Bombing, assassinating, torturing, and displacing said native people is textbook colonization. The idea of Zionism sounds great on paper, however in practice it is malicious in nature. Palestinians have been open to living in harmony with Jewish people, so anti-Semitism is not the issue as Israel wants people to believe.
The issue is that Israel has no intention of living in harmony with Palestinians, but to instead wipe them from existence and claim their land, their culture, and their history as their… Read more
@9KMMZHV1yr1Y
Isreal was home to Jewish nomadic tribes from antiquity. Palestine (philistina) was labeled and formed under the Roman empire as an affront to northern (Israel) and southern (Juda) jewish kingdoms as a means to control them.
@9KG93JL1yr1Y
People are tribal, and feel strong emotional connections to places. As a descendant of immigrants, this concept does not resonate to me. People also want a homeland where they feel safe. As a descendant of Holocaust victims, the concept of a place where Jews can feel fre from persecution resonates strongly with me.
@9KG8LPV1yr1Y
the right and power of a governing body to govern itself, its people and its lands without outside interference.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How do you perceive your role in supporting or questioning the establishment of homelands for cultural or religious groups?
In my opinion, Zionism itself is extremely harmful and the questioning of it is not anti-semetic. I am supportive of Judaism and Jewish people but the horrible things happening in Palestine are not to be excused by the past struggles of any one group. Many Jewish people not only support Palestine but see Zionism as anti-semetic in and of itself.
@9KVPCBB1yr1Y
If it’s part of someone religious practice, it shouldn’t be judged or alienated. Not everyone believes in the same thing, you don’t have to agree with it but you shouldn’t bring harm to it if it isn’t physically harming others.
@9KVP53R1yr1Y
i’m not really interested in foreign wars that have nothing to do with us as a country. yes i understand as a nation its our duty to protect those in need. but at the same time we are spending billions of dollars on a war that shouldn’t be happening. we need to focus on OUR problems rather than some other war 1000s of miles away.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How should one's personal connection to their ancestors' land impact current geopolitical boundaries, if at all?
@9KW34FQ1yr1Y
I feel like in most cases people should be able to keep their ancestors' land.
@9KZ78SQ 1yr1Y
To say most cases is bold, I believe that in [some] cases people should be able to keep their ancestors land. If they are natives to the area, they shouldn't be uprooted from their home. Though if a group's ancestors resided somewhere else long before their time, I don't believe they have a right to go to where their ancestors lived and claim it as their own, but I believe they should have a right to at least reside their if it will not bother the current society residing in the land.
@9KW3MSD1yr1Y
you should have the right to inheart the land from your ansestors exactly how they left it
@9KW3KXB1yr1Y
They had the right from blood/inheritance to keep what is theirs
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
When, if ever, do you believe it's appropriate to intervene in conflicts over territory and identity?
@9HTT748 1yr1Y
Yes, they need to coexist like they had before British rule, if they can't act like adults and settle things peacefully, and if they can't fight without serious moral and human rights violations, we may have to do something about it.
@9HTSJRQ1yr1Y
I believe that genocide is wrong. It is appropriate to intervene when thousands of people are being murdered for their identity and land they reside on. It is embarrassing the UN has allowed this to happen as long as it has.
When innocent children, women, and men are losing their lives for no reason other than genocide
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
Can the establishment of a nation based on religious or historical claims be justified in a modern, multicultural world?
@9H8NPL92yrs2Y
If it promotes lawful and just practices that keeps citizens free and passive.
Not at all, especially in the context of Israel, which staked a claimed to a land that they had no claim to. Israel is a theocratic apartheid state that prioritizes Israeli Jews over the rest of their population. this is unacceptable.
@9H8NCP62yrs2Y
No , it cannot because that was how it was a long time ago and that didn't work out so well
@9H8PJPM2yrs2Y
The establishment of a state based on religion and historical claims has been seen many times around the world. Israel is not the only country; other Muslim countries, like Pakistan, were founded for the cause of Islam. Other countries have been founded based on religions such as Christianity, like the US and other English-speaking countries.
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
How would you feel if your ancestral homeland was claimed by others based on historical and religious connections?
@9H994YB2yrs2Y
It depends on how much basis they have on the claim and the overall evolution of the land. We also have to consider the old ways people used to be and hold land claims in that regard to different standards.
@9H999XZ 2yrs2Y
This question is difficult, as Israel did at one point have claim to the land before being driven out by war. Ultimately, I side with Israel due to their historical and religous claim on the land.
@9H98SBYRepublican2yrs2Y
I would feel bad for the people that were hurt in the claiming of the land, but as long as the people that the land was taken from were treated as equals, it would be okay.
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
How can we ensure history’s tragic events are not repeated when forming new nations?
@9HN9QFQ2yrs2Y
We teach about it and not let people forget to make the same mistakes.
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
How can competing historical narratives about a land shape its future?
@9HN98QY2yrs2Y
I think that it doesn't really do that but history helps us recognize recurring patterns, identify societal strengths and weaknesses, and learn from past mistakes to build a better future
@9HN8Z7V2yrs2Y
It shouldn't matter how a people arrived at a land, they are entitled to peace and should not be forcibly removed
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
Is it possible to fully support the rights of one group without infringing on those of another in contests over land?
@9HN9VRF 2yrs2Y
This is a very complex issue that can't be fully addressed here but I believe that both sides should engage in peace talks and organizations should be put in place to encourage civil interactions between civilians of both sides. The only way this will ever get better is if both sides can stop seeing the other side as "not human" or unworthy, which can only really come from interacting and understanding. I believe a model that a solution could be based off of is "the Troubles" in Ireland. I also believe that Palestinians whose homes were destroyed should be prioritized in the sense that they should be a priority to be heard at the peace talks and it should be ensured that they receive appropriate housing as soon as possible.
@9HN9FPS2yrs2Y
yes. I can support Jews and still criticize the actions of Israel against Palestine. the Israelis do not represent all Jews, and many Jews, including Holocaust survivors, condemn Israel for its actions. additionally, there are also Jewish Palestinians.
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
How would you balance the historical suffering of one people with the current suffering of another in claims to the same land?
@9H5SJD92yrs2Y
I would try to draw similarities between the two and find the perfect balance between them.
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
What steps can be taken to respect the rights of all parties involved in a territorial dispute?
@9HN983S2yrs2Y
abolish the Israeli apartheid government and control over the area and genocide, 1 state solution of life on both sides
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
What is the strongest emotional argument you could make in favor of or against the establishment of a new nation?
@9KLKS3Y1yr1Y
I believe the Jewish should get their homes back, the only reason why they were removed from Israel was due to the Roman Empire removing them from their homeland and proceeding to name that land after their enemies, which is why it is called Palestine to this day. So in essence, the Jewish should be able to obtain their land back.
@9KLK3LGRepublican1yr1Y
The Jewish people deserve their own nation, and I believe that that nation should include Israel.
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
In what ways has the search for belonging impacted your life or that of someone you know?
@9J7WWWL1yr1Y
I think that everyone should have a place/land to call home. In a perfect world, everyone regardless of their race, religion, political views, sexual orientation, etc. could live peacefully anywhere they desired. Unfortunately, we don't, and until we do let the Jewish people have Israel.
@9J7WPDL1yr1Y
Zionism hasn't effected my life in any way, though I will say that don't agree with nationalism that's solely based on religion (Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, etc.).
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
How can we navigate our devotion to our own cultural identities while respecting others' rights and traditions?
@9J3SDDY1yr1Y
I don't know if there is an easy answer to this. The most important thing is to set rules and laws to prevent criminal/malicious acts.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
In what way might the search for a homeland and self-determination affect international relations and global peace?
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
When does preserving cultural heritage become problematic in the context of nation-building and territorial claims?
@9JDG55RRepublican1yr1Y
I don't think that it is a big issue people should choose if they want to rebuild Isreal., It shouldn't be funded by gov though, it should be funded by people who care about that particular issue,
It can become bad it others dont agree or when it happens and it causes problems.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How would you feel about migrating to a land that has historical significance to you but is currently inhabited by others?
@9JBJMC8Independent1yr1Y
I should be able to move there. Don't kick others out, but my historic ties to the area should not be discredited.
@9JBJBFK1yr1Y
Leave them be. As long as it’s peaceful things are fine.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How do divergent historical narratives influence your view on the legitimacy of territorial claims?
@9KS6ZJQ1yr1Y
I believe that if you determine that Palestine had the territory and land then you must also consider that Israel had the land before even them. Yet I don't necessarily believe in the idea of someone having a right to land. Instead I believe that if someone were to be conquered than their ownership is depleted. Israel taking over Palestine through force after attempted peace simply results in the creation of Israel.
@9CJ6CB61yr1Y
Israel was handed over by foreign powers, via military assistance for conservative Zionist forces, who quite literally stated that their forces was on the colonization of the Palestinian region, justified by their religious texts. They had NO legal right, the Palestinian region was territory of the British because they were conquering Nazi invaded land. If the British are the “good guys”, and those who benefitted from the occupation were the “good guys”, then they’d be seeking the autonomy of the Palestinian state, not invading and OPENLY shoving the Palestinian… Read more
@9KS6PQJ1yr1Y
I don't think that territorial claims should be determined by divergent historical narratives.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
Why might the desire for a community's self-preservation resonate with you, or why might it not?
@9JSWG351yr1Y
I response to the topic of "Zionism" the desire of a communities self- preservation resonates with me in the sense that, I feel as if it makes sense that those in the Zionism movement would want to maintain their territory and self preserve what they have already claimed. It is hard to understand fully and have an input on the topic due to the fact that I personally am not connected to Zionism and I am also not residing where this conflict is occurring. I am sure that others will have different points and understandings on this depending on where you live and what you identify with.
@9JSW9YK1yr1Y
I believe the Jewish community should be safe but I don't think that safety is found by attacking other countries and taking their land and homes.
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
Can the desire for self-determination justify the displacement of others?
@9HN9MFF2yrs2Y
The desire for self-determination is not justified by the displacement of others. It's selfish.
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
How important is it for a community to have a geographical space where they feel they truly belong?
Community is important, what isreal is doing isnt building their community, its genocide.
@9HSML7T2yrs2Y
Zionism encapsulates the confrontation between the Global North and Global South. I refute the idea that a Jewish ethnostate is required for Jews to "feel like they truly belong."
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How might the concept of a 'promised land' influence your personal aspirations or fears?
@9KVNRBH1yr1Y
The concept of a ' promised land ' influence my personal influence my personal aspirations or fears is having an understanding from the mother land.
It doesn’t Israel can’t just annex another country and genocide its people.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
What does the saying 'a person's home is their castle' mean to you in the context of historical territorial claims?
@9KW5227Republican1yr1Y
In the context of historical territorial claims, the saying "a person's home is their castle" conveys the notion of property rights and the inherent right of individuals to defend and control their land. It emphasizes the idea that one's home, like a medieval castle, symbolizes sovereignty and autonomy over territory, highlighting the importance of protecting one's property against external threats.
@9KW3X4G1yr1Y
a persons home is a persons home and you should leave them alone unless they did something to you
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
Should the world's approach to global refugee crises mirror the support given to the Jewish people's struggle for a homeland?
@9H9N4JH2yrs2Y
The idea of Jewish people having their own country is fine but the war they are causing in Palestine is not.
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
How do you define 'belonging' and has there ever been a time when you've fought to belong somewhere?
@9J3S49M1yr1Y
My Sophomore year, I fought to get in to a higher Choir
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
What are the potential risks and rewards of creating a nation based on shared identity?
@9HMHC6R2yrs2Y
I like the way things are now, I feel like lots of change at once can be destructive.
@ISIDEWITH2yrs2Y
How important is it to have a nation state for a particular cultural or religious community in today's world?
@9H3Q3VZ2yrs2Y
Zionism is the movement for the self-determination and statehood for the Jewish people in their ancestral homeland, the land of Israel.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How would you feel if your cultural or religious identity was subject to debate in the global political arena?
@9KVMT291yr1Y
Zionism being the only acceptable stance for Jewish people is antisemitic
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
Can you imagine a scenario where you would be willing to relocate for the greater good of a larger community?
@9KDJPZD1yr1Y
If our country needed more room for imigrants I would move to another counrty, or if there was an overpopulation in my state I would move as well.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How could you reconcile your desire for peace with the demands of a group seeking to establish their own state?
@9KG82TZ1yr1Y
Trying to establish a state filled with your own people is inherently racist and is commonly referred to as an ethnostate, which is exactly what the Nazis were trying to establish. All peoples who act in a manner to promote harmony with all peoples deserve respect and peace should be sought after especially if one has the power to operate as such.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
Have you ever felt a sense of solidarity with a group fighting for recognition and their own space?
@9KG85GS1yr1Y
I have but not on as large of a level as many others have.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
How would you define a 'homeland' and what emotional significance does it hold for you?
@9KG888B1yr1Y
Zionism is nationalism taken too far. I hate nationalism.
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.
