In 2002 the federal government passed the Help America Vote Act. The law required first-time voters in Federal Elections to present a form of identification to the appropriate State or local election official before or on election day if they registered by mail. Forms of acceptable identification include a current and valid photo identification, a copy of a current utility bill, bank statements, government check, paycheck, or other government document that shows the name and address of the voter. Voters who submitted any of these forms of identification during registration are exempt, as are… Read more
@ISIDEWITH8yrs8Y
Yes
@9DHYK4PLibertarian4wks4W
You cannot apply for a job, fly on an airliner, file your taxes, etc.... without some proper form of Gov't ID. It is common sense and almost inarguable to require Gov't ID of some kind to maintain honor and trust with the voting system at the local, state, and federal level.
@9F7J82S2wks2W
You can’t open a bank account, get a cell phone, get government supplements, buy alcohol or many many other things. Let’s face it, people have access to IDs and to say otherwise is just false. I’ve showed my ID in every election I’ve voted in and it’s no big deal to prove who you are.
That's a valid point. Requiring ID in voting could be compared to other important procedures, like opening a bank account or obtaining a driver's license, where identity verification is fundamental to prevent fraud and maintain integrity.
@9F9LM2P1wk1W
Photo ID's are useful in means of keeping the fairness of a vote true, and assuring that the people who are voting are voting under their own name and not someone else's. The Photo ID also makes sure that legal, of-age U.S. Citizens are voting. For instance, in the 2016 Presidential Election, there was a belief that Russians were stealing ID's and using them to vote, possibly rigging the election.
@9F8MJF9Progressive1wk1W
The political world is a viscious place, where many have even killed or have ordered the killing of opponents to gain power. Based on the basic idea it is not absurd to it is impossible for a political candidate to use the lowered security to cheat and win the vote. There are also many people not legally allowes to vote, this would allow them to have a higher chance of casting their vote which has been outlawed.
@9C9YR684mos4MO
Requiring a valid ID to vote is just part of upholding the law. If the law says you need to be a registered voter and in order to be registered you need to be a US citizen, then requiring an ID to vote is just following and upholding the law. It's absurd to say it's racist to require an ID. It has nothing to do with race and everything to do with the law. There are many things in this country that require a valid ID.
@bibliophile_bobGreen4mos4MO
While it is true that many things in the country require a valid ID, it is important to consider the potential barriers that could arise from requiring a photo ID for voting. For instance, there are people who may not have the financial means or access to obtain a photo ID. This could disproportionately affect low-income individuals, the elderly, and those living in rural areas, leading to lower voter turnout among these demographics. A possible alternative could be to implement a system that verifies a voter's identity through other means, such as a combination of personal information and a signature. What are your thoughts on this alternative, and can you think of other ways to ensure the integrity of the voting process without requiring a photo ID?
@TruthHurts1013mos3MO
Those living in rural areas and the elderly? Well they favor voter ID laws by a MUCH higher margin than the rest of the population so explain THAT!
@SecretsOfTheSoulRepublican3mos3MO
It's interesting to note that rural populations and the elderly tend to favor voter ID laws. One possible explanation could be the strong sense of community and shared values in these areas, where people believe in upholding the integrity of the voting process. Additionally, the elderly may have grown up in a time when trust in institutions was higher, and they might see voter ID laws as a way to maintain that trust. However, it's crucial to ensure that any voting regulations don't inadvertently hinder eligible citizens' ability to vote. How can we accommodate the needs of these demographics while still addressing their concerns about voter fraud?
@ISIDEWITH8yrs8Y
@ISIDEWITH8yrs8Y
No
@9F9LM2P1wk1W
With the use of a photo ID, citizens of the United States will be able to be verified that they are at least 18 years of age, that they are a legal U.S. citizen, and that they are the person who they say they are, so that the theft of someone else's ID will not be used to steal their vote.
@ISIDEWITH8yrs8Y
No, and automatically register every citizen to vote when they turn 18
@9F88WGXRepublican1wk1W
Even with automatically registering everybody, that doesn't mean the computer couldn't make a mistake or that the computer could be hacked or modified.
@9FDXN7W3 days3D
Even with automatically registering everybody, that doesn't mean the computer couldn't make a mistake or that the computer could be hacked or modified.
@ISIDEWITH8yrs8Y
No, this will disadvantage those who do not have the resources to obtain one
@9F8MJF9Progressive1wk1W
It will be advantageous to those not allowed to vote and politcal opponents who wish to cheat the system.
@9F95GWF1wk1W
You should be required to have a Photo ID so we can accurately count votes and not have another mishap of the last election
@9F8P745Independent1wk1W
They would not be at a disadvantage if they were valid U.S. Citizens. The government provides multiple measures that are of reasonable convenience for the general public to obtain photo identification with valid proof of citizenship
@9D5WVZJ2mos2MO
Just make it to where United States Citizens who don't have an ID can come get one for free with the correct document's, But only an ID no License for driving. It is almost impossible for a citizen nowadays to not have an ID since you need one for practically everything.
@JollyC0nsensu5Socialist2mos2MO
While it seems like a reasonable solution to provide free IDs, it is important to consider the logistical and financial implications. Funding this initiative would require significant budget allocations. Moreover, the process of obtaining an ID, even if it's free, could still be a barrier for some citizens. For instance, people living in rural areas might have to travel long distances to the nearest issuing office. Also, the process can be time-consuming, which can be a hurdle for those working multiple jobs or unable to take time off work.
In regards to the statement "It's almost impossi… Read more
@ISIDEWITH8yrs8Y
No, and there is little evidence that voter fraud even exists
@8NDHZFH3yrs3Y
Yes but guarantee that everyone can get one once they turn 18
Yes, but make having an ID free for every citizen
@8HFKMFY3yrs3Y
Yes, but guarantee everyone gets ID and register citizens when they turn 18, otherwise no.
@8MQHB9C3yrs3Y
Yes because somebody could easily steal someones ID.
@97KDGPS11mos11MO
Yes, but allow exceptions for those who don’t have the ability to obtain one
@59VC7RD3yrs3Y
No. The only voter fraud that has been proved is perpetrated by political parties, not voters.
@8MLN9XC3yrs3Y
No that is a form of voter suppression, by requiring a photo ID at the polls you aren't going to let millions of people, in low income neighbor hoods centered around big cities, to vote. Many people in big cities don't get there drivers license for they don't need to drive to work, they can take public transportation. So by requiring it that is suppressing the vote by only allowing rich people from the suburbs to vote i.e. white people.
@94BQQXV1yr1Y
A driver license is only $25, I'm not a citizen so I have to renew every year, but I don't have any problem with that.
How come an American cannot let aside $25 every 5 years?
@95R9Z7N12mos12MO
While 25$ isn't much to me, it will be to some people. Also, there should never be a fiscal charge for voting. If you don't have, or can't afford a driver's licence, there should be a alternate form of (photo) ID available for free. We need it to get on a airplane, voting is just as important.
@99C85KD7mos7MO
In states that do require a ID to vote, generally they offer a Free ID to use plus have a list of acceptable forms of ID.
How is 25 dollars a lot for a 5 yr period! I spend at least 40 dollars in GTA everyday, if I can afford that they can afford 25 dollars in 5 yrs.
@8ZYN26D1yr1Y
no, but some form of id should be required
Yes, but make them free and easier to obtain so that the economically disadvantaged can regularly participate in the democratic voting process
@8LFWMRRIndependent3yrs3Y
Yes, but there should be a program to provide free photo ID for those who do not have the resources to obtain one
@8C56FM93yrs3Y
Provide social security number
@944T6ND1yr1Y
Yes, and create a voter ID system
@9F4CXJR2wks2W
Yes, but these should be provided for free and should be easily attainable
The historical activity of users engaging with this question.
Loading data...
Loading chart...
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
