Should foreign lobbyists be allowed to raise money for American elections?
In the 2020 U.S. federal election foreign lobbyists donated more than $33.5 million to candidates, political parties, and interest groups. In the United States foreign nationals are prohibited by law from making contributions to political groups or campaigns to influence U.S. elections. Foreign nationals can hire foreign agents or lobbyists to advocate for their interests and make political contributions on their behalf. The Foreign Agents Registration Act is a United States law that imposes public disclosure requirements and other legal obligations on persons representing foreign interests…
Read moreNarrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Political theme:
Voting for candidate:
City:
@ISIDEWITH8yrs8Y
No
@98ZSZ492yrs2Y
No party (left or right) in the US supports this. It only benefits foreign adversaries.
@9F7KHZM2yrs2Y
No, all forms of lobbying should be banned.
@9D3RPBQ2yrs2Y
The ethics of foreign lobbyists are unethical and lobbyists should be banned, And Lobbying undermines democracy.
@93YBTNL3yrs3Y
No, Lobbying should be banned.
@9DQQ6LH2yrs2Y
No, and nobody should be donating to politicians.
@989RCLL2yrs2Y
No, lobbyists shouldn’t be raising money for elections
@9S2PDWW9mos9MO
Foreign lobbyist that operate in the United States should be Investigated based upon their country of origin, the industry or profession they represent, and if they have a history of criminality or corruption. It should also be noted that American politicians are not adherence to foreigners But they are adherence to American citizens, and this must be reinforced and reminded at all times that the needs of American citizens come before the needs of foreigners.
@B4G9PQY1mo1MO
having any foreign influence in our politics could leave a negative impact on how we function as a people/country.
@ye 1mo1MO
No, and severely punish and ban AIPAC, foreign interests should not be able to buy the influence of our politicians
@B3ZYM5D2mos2MO
No, for the sake of national security and combating potential treason and terrorism, foreign lobbyists should be banned from raising money for US elections
@B3VGV2T 2mos2MO
Federal law prohibits contributions, donations, expenditures(including independent expenditures) and disbursements solicited, directed, received or made directly or indirectly by or from foreign nationals in connection with any federal, state or local election.
@B3N9XXH2mos2MO
Yes, but there should be a time frame that they have resided in the U.S. before they can do this to avoid influences on elections by outside governments.
@BNB_yee 2mos2MO
No; and any candidate or associate of a candidate for an American election that knowingly and willingly conspires with a foreign entity to receive funds for their election or to manipulate election results must be immediately investigated and indicted for likely subversive activities.
@B3RS8MT2mos2MO
public funding for campaigns. 2 Candidates. One fundraises 5 million more than the other. The lesser of the two gets the difference between what they raised through their own efforts. The race is to see who is the best candidate not who has the most wealth donors.
@8VGYZK8 2yrs2Y
Yes, as long as the entity they're representing isn't receiving money from the US government
@9D7CLZ62yrs2Y
No, and abolish corporate lobbying
Yes, but said foreign entities must conform to paralleled limit amounts and publication of domestic corporations.
@9D644HF2yrs2Y
Yes of course they are people and banning them is highly racist. Also encourage socialist and democratic principles.
No, If they have an issue with the US, they should take it before the UN
@9D45DHZ2yrs2Y
Yes, as long as they are an ally
@95YSQRZ3yrs3Y
No, lobbying should not exist
@8Q8K98H4yrs4Y
@B35JXRW3mos3MO
No. Because although who is in a place of importance in the U.S is important to foreign places, the most important is to the U.S citizens and there should be complete unbiased to the people running for those roles.
@B2KLHW93mos3MO
I would have to be something people are aware of that is going on and that they are gauged for the influence
@B2FNVYT4mos4MO
Absolutely not. I don't believe lobbying should be legal at all. Those who lobby to pass laws do not do it in the interest of the citizens; they do it to further their own. And the laws that they lobby to pass are often harmful.
@B2B3DCM4mos4MO
Yes, but it should be an anonymous donation so the money can still help with whatever it is donated for but hold no upper hand or affiliation to who or what the money is going too
@9ZHMWMJ6mos6MO
Yes, but must strictly restrict the amount and origins and make sure no more than 10% of the domestic amounts
@9Y3TQBP6mos6MO
All donations for politicians should should have their source and amount be easily and publicly accessible
@9XL9KP2Republican6mos6MO
No due to the fact that they could say that they are raising money for them yet it is just for themselves.
@9XHFG4X6mos6MO
If need to learn more before weighting in. My instinct is that it should be permitted, but limited in size, with extensive reporting and disclosures ensuring that it's never used as a back channel. If that id too hard or too big a risk to adequately safeguard against, then A ban sounds ok to me.
@9WS6SQ67mos7MO
It ticks me off that people are so cowardly as to collapse to bribery. Outside influence should have no power over what we do. So it is to the shame of our own cowardly candidates that would cave to bribery. The short answer… it shouldn’t matter.
Yes, they are allowed to, however, it would be more patriotic if we had an American citizen representing them.
@9W4SPVJLibertarian7mos7MO
Yes, but all donations should go to an equal access fund that splits donations evenly between major candidates.
@9W4SGSY7mos7MO
Yes, but as long as they are not just raising money for themselves. If they say they are raising it for a certain person it actually needs to go to that person.
@9TTPNT8 8mos8MO
I don't think this question is clear enough. Foreign interests in our elections is a red line that must not be crossed. However, when it comes to a foreign lobbyist fundraising in the US for a US election, it's a bit of a gray area—it's just business. Transparency is key here; the public should know who's contributing and why. Money shouldn't buy our politicians' favor, and Americans deserve to know the origins of every dollar that enters the political arena.
@9S5NLJC9mos9MO
foreigners have no rights in our country and shouldn't have rights,they need to stay in their own country
@9RWZLPK 9mos9MO
No, to prevent corruption, foreign interests should not be able to buy the influence of politicians. That applies to Americans as well.
@9RRRNQ29mos9MO
No, the federal government should not spend taxpayer money on this. American lobbyists should not be allowed to raise money for foreign elections, either. Foreign interests should not be able to buy the influence of politicians.
@9RJPSYN10mos10MO
No, absolutely not! In fact all lobbying and lobbyists should be abolished. Starting with the foreign lobby. Foreign powers or interests should hold ZERO affect over the actions of the senators and representatives of the government. Period.
@9N8MT4F 10mos10MO
No, and it is the government's responsibility to set limits on this issue. Foreign interests should not be able to buy the influence of our politicians.
@floradora 10mos10MO
I don't think this question is clear enough... foreign interests should not influence our elections... but a foreign lobbyist raising money in the US for a US election seems okay... just a job.
@9P3XJTK11mos11MO
Yes, as long as all donations are limited and public knowledge to ensure there is no conflict of interest
@9P3GXBV11mos11MO
Only individuals should be allowed to contribute to elections. But they should be public information.
@9NKVSCT11mos11MO
Yes, but only as long as the money won’t be used as a way to buy the influence of our politicians and US citizens know who and where the money comes from.
@9MRL3LT12mos12MO
I believe if Candidates want money from foreigners then there should be no debate about weather they could vote, run for president,etc. if you can accept/want their money we could accept them as people
@Politics_5312mos12MO
Yes as long as all donations are public knowledge to ensure there is no conflict of interest and it did exceed more than 30 percent of the total amount of the politicians campaigning.
@9MFX8R712mos12MO
America should not have elections. A king should be chosen by lottery, or by succession of the firstborn son.
@9MF633D12mos12MO
this issue has always been irrelevant as it speaks to the ethics of the candidate receiving the funds, not to the donor
@9M7X92J1yr1Y
Definitely no! I pray to God that you are able to see what I wrote about foreign bribery and what it has already done to our nation. Please we can not allow bribery and stay free. We have already lost our liberty to our enemies the Chinese.
@9L7N2XG1yr1Y
No and they should never influence politicians because the American government is served by the interests of its citizens.
@9KWD3FL1yr1Y
No, foreigners should not be allowed to buy influence and lobbying should be made illegal. As in, serve prison time. A long time. Not just a slap on the wrist, or a fine to pay. But serving actual, hard time. No first offenders act.
@9KVP56LLibertarian1yr1Y
No, foreign interests should have no influence in American politics as well as any foreign interest in American political support being made public knowledge
@9KLCVDR1yr1Y
Yes, but only after completing a strict vetting process to ensure no conflict of interest and to prevent corruption
Deleted1yr1Y
Both Yes and No, as long as all donations are public knowledge to ensure there is no conflict of interest; foreign interests should not be able to buy the influence of our politicians.
@9JZR5D4Republican1yr1Y
No, only citizens (whether natural-born or naturalized) who are natural persons (no corporations, PACs, unions or lobbyist groups) should be allowed to donate.
@9JXNVY51yr1Y
Yes, but under certain restrictions to ensure that the donating party is not trying to promote a weak or corrupt candidate.
@9J43VSX1yr1Y
Yes, as long as all donations are public knowledge, have no conflict of interest, and these donations are limited by value.
@9GKLBL7Independent2yrs2Y
I don't really know what a lobbyist is but it is an American election so people from foreign places I feel should not be allowed to raise money.
@9FPKZJXIndependent2yrs2Y
No, as this could cause more corruption
@9FBH7MJ2yrs2Y
@9F9878N2yrs2Y
No, and it should be illegal to accept foreign campaign donations.
@9F3N5VL2yrs2Y
No, and the ones masquerading as American-foreign alliances shouldn’t either
@9DZLFNH2yrs2Y
It depends on what they are doing with it.
@9DWCC782yrs2Y
Doesn't matter, dissolve the government
@9DRQ3JY2yrs2Y
Lobbyists should be banned entirely
@9DRHX76 2yrs2Y
Lobbying should be illegal, and all campaigns should be publicly funded
@9DR77HZLibertarian2yrs2Y
Yes, if they classify as an American citizen
@9DL69LZ2yrs2Y
I don't understand this question.
@9DK4SG82yrs2Y
We can’t be hypocrites. We do our best to try and get foreign officials we want voted in office.
@9DFN5BK2yrs2Y
I do not have the knowledge to make an accurate vote.
@9DCZQZ42yrs2Y
Not sufficiently well-informed to make a judgement
@9DBLV5J2yrs2Y
Yes but only if they are citizens and understand American politics.
@9DB3QRF2yrs2Y
No, countries, including ours, should not be bought by foreign influences as this undermines security and stability as a nation
@9D9VZF32yrs2Y
No these Lobbyists could be of enemy countries
@9W5N2VC 7mos7MO
There should be a limit on how much a political party can gain from foreign lobbyists through donations.
@9SKQQD7Republican9mos9MO
I don't see anything wrong with it if they have or are trying to gain citizenship or plan to reside in the U.S.
@8V6TLWM4yrs4Y
No, ban all forms of lobbying
@97KSZBQ3yrs3Y
Yes, but we also need reform for more transparency and enforcement of FARA.
@LiamHal786386403yrs3Y
Ban all forms of lobbying
@96J2MQ73yrs3Y
No, and make all elections publicly funded
No, foreign individuals should not have any influence in the US political system elections and should have no input financially or otherwise.
@8RGHBSP4yrs4Y
No, and make all donations public knowledge
@8CRXL5L5yrs5Y
Get rid of all foreign lobbying.
@8P4HXB54yrs4Y
No, and establish public funding of elections.
No, and lobbying altogether needs to be banned.
@986NH852yrs2Y
I don’t really know what this mean but I mean if it’s a positive Impact then yeah
@972746P3yrs3Y
No this would make public loose its confidence in government.
@96T2WVQ3yrs3Y
No, foreign interests should not be able to buy the influence of our politicians THEY ARE NOT CITIZENS therefore have NO SKIN in the game. These are OUR REPRESENTATIVE EMPLOYEES!
No, and all lobbying should be banned
Yes, as long as they are long-term residents of the US.
All lobbying should be banned.
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.