Should the US increase or decrease the amount of temporary work visas given to high-skilled immigrant workers?
Skilled temporary work visas are usually given to foreign scientists, engineers, programmers, architects, executives, and other positions or fields where demand outpaces supply. Most businesses argue that hiring skilled foreign workers allows them to competitively fill positions which are in high demand. Opponents argue that skilled immigrants decrease middle class wages and job tenure.
Narrow down which types of responses you would like to see.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
@ISIDEWITH9yrs9Y
Increase
@9FR42X9Women’s Equality2yrs2Y
If we increase the amount of visas given out to skilled immigrants there will be better people in America and we will be more diverse also it would give those immigrants a chance to a way better life.
@9LFKBXJ1yr1Y
However, theu should be paid at the same rate as any other worker in that field, companies should be prevented from taking advantage of immigrants workers to steal wages as profits.
@9LMN9SY1yr1Y
Research shows that skilled immigrants drive innovation, create jobs, and fill critical labor gaps. There’s a lot of trades in high demand and with this new generation there’s going to be a lot of jobs not filled
@9FS34DR2yrs2Y
mmigrants are essential workers. Undocumented immigrants make up approximately 3.2 percent of the country's population, but the 7 million who are employed make up 4.4 percent of the workforce
@9LFKBXJ1yr1Y
And they should be paid at the same rate as any other worker in that career, a equitable, fair, livable wage.
@9G6KGZC2yrs2Y
Skilled immigrants travel to the USA to live a better life or have a better life for there kids. So giving them a job they earned seems like no problem
@ISIDEWITH9yrs9Y
Decrease
@9LYFHFL1yr1Y
The country would benefit from a diverse set of intelligent perspectives. My issue is with the definition of skilled often lying in level of college education, whereas I don't think that's always representative of someones abilities or intelligence.
@9LMN9SY1yr1Y
Immigrant are hard workers. They get stuff done in ways many americans can’t. I’d say skilled immigrants are highly valued if they’re all hard workers like most of them
@9FS34DR2yrs2Y
mmigrants comprised 13.6 percent of the total U.S. population in 2021, a slight decrease from the 13.7 percent share they comprised in 2019 and short of the record high of 14.8 percent in 1890
@9FR42X9Women’s Equality2yrs2Y
If there are more talented people of different cultures and countries it would make America a way better place.
@ISIDEWITH9yrs9Y
Decrease, and the government should provide more incentives to prepare our citizens for these jobs
@9G6KGZC2yrs2Y
I feel that if immigrants are more skilled then they should get the job but, yes we should have more jobs for the american people but, can the government really do that.
@ISIDEWITH9yrs9Y
Increase, our economy relies on businesses hiring the highest skilled workers at the lowest cost
@TheHillbillyLordRepublican3mos3MO
We should increase, because immigrants, especially illegal ones, are willing to do a lot of menial labor for lower pay than the average American. This is because they are desperate to do anything to earn a wage and be able to stay here since they aren't here legally so they are afraid of being deported. They should not get a fair pay though. If they are coming here to escape poverty or violence in their country and they demand fair pay, they are ungrateful brats who should be deported immediately. We should cut off all government aid to illegals, and deport them unless if they work for us. Working illegals are actually useful to the economy since they can provide us cheap labor, so deporting them would not be a wise choice. Just deport the useless ones, the ones who don't work and live off of government aid.
@ISIDEWITH9yrs9Y
Decrease, companies are currently taking advantage of this program to decrease wages
@99VCJX4Libertarian2yrs2Y
It's astounding how many people don't understand this.
@TheHillbillyLordRepublican3mos3MO
Isn't that good, to decrease wages? That way, their products will be cheaper for citizens to buy.
Increase for the economy’s sake, but penalize companies that abuse this program to reduce wages and provide more programs to prepare our own citizens to compete for these jobs.
@TheHillbillyLordRepublican3mos3MO
The whole point of letting illegals stay and work, is because they can work for lower wages, since they don't get fair pay rights. Citizens would not want to do many of the jobs that the illegals do, for the lower pay the illegals are doing it for.
@chickentaco4yrs4Y
Increase, but penalize companies taking advantage of this program to decrease wages. But only increase if we don't have enough skilled workers in the U.S. already.
@TheHillbillyLordRepublican3mos3MO
Don't you know that if a company is paying their workers a lower wage, then their products will be cheaper for citizens to buy, since the cost to manufacture or attain them was cheaper in the first place. And cheaper prices of goods is good for the economy. Ofc, if it was a citizen working, that wouldn't be fair pay, but illegals don't get fair pay, so they can work for a lower wage.
@587QZFY5yrs5Y
Greed in America has college grads expecting wages that long time workers have...THERE is a thing about learning and starting at the bottom...and if companies can find foreign workers who appreciate what they are paid...that's ok...
@3PLD6WQ5yrs5Y
Increase the amount. There are so many jobs that high-skilled immigrant workers do that U S citizens would never do even if it meant unemployment for them. Businesses should not take advantage of these high-skilled immigrant workers by paying them cheap wages. I believe they should earn a fair wage.
@TheHillbillyLordRepublican3mos3MO
Businesses should take advantage of this by paying the illegals a lower wage, that way their products can be cheaper. It's called capitalism, hiring workers for the lowest pay, and it is good for the economy.
@3PMDT3J5yrs5Y
the US is one of the hardest countries to get a skilled work visa, we want to be able to go overseas and work in other countries but we don't want to reciprocate. In the interest of cooperation, we should make it easier to get these visas, so that we can receive them ourselves if so desired.
@99H6Y7Z2yrs2Y
Decrease and ban asian immigration
@B4CHTPVIndependent1mo1MO
Decrease, as the nation is being too reliant on immigrants and it lowers the quality of life for citizens.
@9FCKLN32yrs2Y
Abolish the quota system and replace it with a point based system
@9L4Z23BIndependent 1yr1Y
Increase, there should be no limit for immigrants who are healthy, educated, and financially take care of themself
@9DWYW2B2yrs2Y
Decrease and decrease oriental immigration
@Jones4Potus2024 2yrs2Y
Increase, but make sure these immigrants are being paid the federal or state minimum wage of whatever state they are working in.
@9DL4ZD82yrs2Y
Abolish quotas and switch to a point based system
@9SLDRDJ9mos9MO
Maintain the current amount for the economy’s sake, but penalize companies that abuse this program to reduce wages and working conditions and provide more incentives to help prepare our own citizens to compete for these jobs
@9GT9LJR1yr1Y
Stay the same, add incentives to make more Americans with a passion for more skilled jobs to take the risk.
@9GN5KWP2yrs2Y
Increase for the economy’s sake, but also penalize companies that abuse this program to reduce wages and increase efforts to prepare our own citizens to compete for such jobs
Increase for the economy’s sake but also institute more programs to prepare our own citizens for these jobs and fine any companies that exploit such programs to decrease wages or working standards.
@84ZWD6LLibertarian3yrs3Y
Increase, but reform K-12 curriculum + expand access to higher education (trade/vocational schools, community/4 year public colleges) to prepare Americans for these jobs
@5H6V8BL5yrs5Y
The high-skilled standard is ableist and excludes immigrants who do not meet ridiculous standards. You can't place the value of a person on their ability.
@8RQRNPY4yrs4Y
Increase, along with a tougher stance against illegal immigration
@9CYRMGF2yrs2Y
Decrease and reduce the cost of the citizenship application process
@9DZZXKP2yrs2Y
Increase, but add stricter regulations for companies abusing the system for cheap labor.
@9D7VRVM2yrs2Y
Abolish that, work visas shouldn't exist.
@934B86G3yrs3Y
Increase, our economies rely on businesses hiring high skill for low cost, but fix companies taking advantage of this to decrease wages, and the government should provide more incentive to prepare workers for these jobs.
@9226VW73yrs3Y
Visas should not be required
@8L7SSRC5yrs5Y
Increase, but crack down on companies taking advantage of this program to decrease wages of both domestic and immigrant workers.
@B58JJKS4 days4D
Neither but make sure that all visa requirements are necessary to qualify for legal visa status but should check when visa applications are expired and make sure they are qualified for the next round of visa applications
@B562ZC61wk1W
There should be no change in the amount given. But they shoulincrease the advantages, wage, and benefits given to immigrant workers.
Decrease, they should be allowed to work in the US without restriction and offered citizenship if they decide to stay.
@B55JSH41wk1W
Keep it the same, but expand the program to cover nurses and doctors immigrating into the u.s, and require migrants be paid the same wages as citizen workers.
Increase, but do something about businesses taking advantage of these workers and giving them lower wages
@B5373LV2wks2W
making the visa programs a lot more safer and works lot more faster so that way there isn't a wait line for anybody and their work is done better. So that way immigrants don't have to rely on "lawyers" they pay to get them a legal visa in a crooked system.
@B4YLMDV2wks2W
Increase, but hold companies accountable for decreased wages towards immigrants with proven high skilled knowledge in their respective fields
People have the right to free movement and there should be no immigration limitations that would allow for the existence of work visas.
@B4RW23Z3wks3W
Decrease, the program is being taken advantage of by immigrants whose culture and values clash with mine.
@ye 3wks3W
Decrease, abolish H-1B visas, and have our government provide more incentives to prepare our citizens for these jobs
@B4KLCSB4wks4W
if there are certain sectors in the job market that need more labor then allow more work visas to be given out
@9ZTQW4V 1mo1MO
Increase the number of high-skilled visas, while also strengthening domestic workforce training and ensuring protections against wage suppression or exploitation.
@B4J7KDH1mo1MO
Increase, but make companies have to pay them the same wage as citizens otherwise it is just exploitation
@B4HVSCX1mo1MO
I believe it is good for skilled workers to come in but they should be paid the same as everyone else.
@B4GWZ4JIndependent1mo1MO
Increase for the short term, but prepare our own citizens for these jobs as well so we can rely on our own citizens to ensure dominance in those fields
@B4FGGSB1mo1MO
Increase if needed in specific fields, but with the restriction that they may not be paid less than median wage in that field, so they are not being used by companies to decrease wages.
@B4FCJW4Republican1mo1MO
Decrease and ban amnesty, visas, green cards, asylum, etc. and only allow citizenship applications the constitutional legal method for the sake of border security.
@B4D6KHP1mo1MO
Decrease and deport them if they are illegal for the sake of border security, national security, health, a good supply chain, low taxes, low national debt, a low unemployment rate, and law and order.
@B4C7QPN1mo1MO
The government needs to decrease this amount until they get control of immigration and figure out who is here illegally now. We have no idea who is still here and I do not think adding more people is going to make this country safer until we find the people here for bad reasons.
@B4C6FCD1mo1MO
Increase, but we shouldn't be using it as a method to outsource work for cheap labor. We should be paying the same amount we'd pay to an American citizen.
@B4B5FVS1mo1MO
Increase it for immigrants that can do the job better than the average American. Otherwise, decrease it.
@B484DKC1mo1MO
The current level is sufficient but we need to better prepare US citizens for these high-skill jobs.
@B45H73W2mos2MO
Increase them as long as they can do the job better than any American. Otherwise, we should be prioritizing our own country folk for these jobs to combat local unemployment.
@B458PS2Independent2mos2MO
Increase temporary work visas given, but increase wages to provide incentives for citizens to also work those jobs and be able to make a living off of them
@B3ZKJBVIndependent2mos2MO
Increase, immigrants should be able to come here and work for more money than they'd get paid somewhere else.
@B3ZGLGT2mos2MO
Increase, but only if the immigrant's pay is comparable to US citizen's pay. Too many companies use immigration to depress wages.
@B3XQXT72mos2MO
Increase and require companies pay immigrants the same as a US citizen while also better preparing US citizens to compete for these jobs.
Continue offering temporary work visas but encourage companies to keep paying any of their workers (US born or otherwise) good wages. Also add incentives to prepare US born people for these jobs.
@B3TCFPJ2mos2MO
Increase, and stop companies that hire them from abusing them or limiting their ability to change jobs.
@B3STJZK2mos2MO
Ensure those who receive the work visa have work mobility and have the ability to fight for fair wages and working conditions. The main reason for an increase in migrant labor over domestic is not a lack of domestic skilled laborers but an ability for corporations to take advantage of high-skilled immigrant workers in a way that domestic workers cannot be taken advantage of.
@B3HF4VR2mos2MO
Regardless, the program needs to be reworked to prevent companies from taking advantage of this program and the immigrant workers.
@TheHillbillyLordRepublican 2mos2MO
Increase, so we can use the illegal immigrants as a means of cheap labor to do the jobs that citizens don't want to do for low pay
@B3DPRMP2mos2MO
Extend the lengths of such visas. Also, how about you grant highly trained and educated immigrants automatic citizenship after 2 renewals of said Visas… As by then, they may have committed to staying in America.
@B3BN2ND2mos2MO
Increase, but monitor businesses to ensure that they are not exploiting the system by lowering wages.
@B3BLW572mos2MO
Temporary work visas are coercive by nature and give employers too much power over their work visa employees
@B3B8VRF2mos2MO
I think we should give out as many as there are people applying, good at what they do, and of course willing to work, however I do think the government should monitor this in case of companies taking advantage of foreigners and giving them decreased wages.
@B37656Q3mos3MO
I don't really think it needs to be decreased necessarily, but the whole program needs to be reworked to give those foreign workers more benefits and maneuverability so they can be treated properly in the work force like a normal american would.
@B36CXTC3mos3MO
Allow people that come h1 visas need to be able to switch jobs rather than be stuck with the exploitative company.
@B35T7Q53mos3MO
Allow companies to import workers only after presenting solid evidence that hiring of domestic workers is impossible.
@B35K9G23mos3MO
Increase, however only from white countries like Switzerland or Hyperborea. Definetly not from India.
@B34HB8P3mos3MO
The government needs to regulate the program they introduced to the world which is the HB1 Visa program. The government is aware bad actors are abusing this system such as Elon musk and need to stop this modern-day slavery. Workers deserve to be paid their fair wages for the work they do.
@B2Z74QW3mos3MO
The current amount of visas would be fine if it were easier to obtain any type of visa. It is much too lengthy of a process to immigrate to the USA.
@B2SY3TL3mos3MO
First of all, there's no such thing as unskilled labor. Second, borders are fake and shouldn't matter.
@B2Q9CDP3mos3MO
I feel like everyone should be able to immigrate to a country regardless if they do useful work or not but instead of attacking or rebelling against the government people should make suggestions to the government about this issue peacefully.
@B2PMTB43mos3MO
Visas should be based per occupational need. If there is a shortage of American workers in some fields, its ok to issue the Visas.
@B2KSJBF3mos3MO
Increase, but only if companies are providing equal wages. Any company found to be undercutting wages with visa employees should be fined - at minimum - double the original wage of the position.
@B2K5ZHP4mos4MO
I would need to see if there’s space for more immigrants to come on visas. If there is, then absolutely.
@B2HZGM64mos4MO
America first but if we make investments in someone that comes here, we should try to keep them here. Increase wages and other things for Americans
@TheHillbillyLordRepublican 4mos4MO
Increase, but only give work visas to immigrants doing menial labor that citizens don't want to do for a lower pay. Any illegal who doesn't want to work for low pay needs to be deported. Hiring skilled workers for the lowest cost is important to helping the economy.
@B2BLXHS4mos4MO
Remove the quota on work visas and replace green cards with a points-based immigration scheme for skilled workers
@B29DB2TIndependent4mos4MO
Increase, but provide protection for the immigrants for wage and treatment, to de-incentivize companies abusing the program to save money.
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.