政治クイズを試してみてください
@ISIDEWITH質問移民12年前

不法移民の子供は市民権を与えられるべきか?

アメリカ合衆国憲法修正第14条は、「アメリカ合衆国で生まれ、あるいは帰化した者、及びその司法権に属することになった者全ては、アメリカ合衆国の市民であり、その住む州の市民である」と述べている。生得権市民権の反対派は、修正第14条は、非合法的にアメリカにいる両親から生まれた子供は自動的に市民であると具体的に述べていないので、はっきりしていないと主張する。賛成派は、修正第14条を撤廃すれば、ここで生まれたそれぞれの子供と共に不法移民の数は増え、アメリカの納税者には数十億ドルもの負担が強いられ、税基盤は縮小するだろうと主張する。

0 応答

 @NB659X Ohioから 答えた…3歳3Y

If they are born here they are citizens, however their parents may be deported as they have committed a crime entering the country illegally. They may apply for citizenship once they have returned to their native country. The child may stay or go and retain citizenship.

 @N9ZSVC Californiaから 答えた…3歳3Y

When you cross into our border you are illegal and all your children born here are illegal like YOU! they should not be citizens. congress needs to change the law and do it NOW and date in back years!

 @MRYML8 Kansasから 答えた…3歳3Y

They should be deported and children born here should not be legal citizens. Boarder protection must increase and shot on the spot if caught.

 @LX72TP Massachusettsから 答えた…3歳3Y

Yes, children born within the borders of the U.S. must be citizens under the text of the Constitution.

 @LX2MKJ Delawareから 答えた…3歳3Y

Yes after a few years and going through citizenship process

 @LWVDHL New Jerseyから 答えた…3歳3Y

Only if they have lived in the US their entire lives and have not lived in the parent's home land.

 @LWRDMD Floridaから 答えた…3歳3Y

Depends on what they are doing with their life. Productive citizens yes, criminal no.

 @LMDSCQ Pennsylvaniaから 答えた…3歳3Y

No, they need to come to America on a certified passport/green card and be able to speak English.

 @GPYGV8 Ohioから 答えた…3歳3Y

There should be a pathway to citizenship for all, especially if brought here against their will

 @GKLJRL Coloradoから 答えた…3歳3Y

The children of course, it is not their fault they are here. Anyone else should have to undergo a procedure to become a citizen but that doesn't mean deny them access. Last I remember, America is a country built by immigrants, we should not view them with hostility just because they didn't migrate here when our ancestors did.

 @FZZ64Z Floridaから 答えた…3歳3Y

It should be based on the constitution

 @358M2G Texasから 答えた…3歳3Y

No. End birth-right citizenship if parents are illegal.

 @69YHS North Carolinaから 答えた…3歳3Y

They should be treated as refugees seeking political asylum and be monitored for criminal activity while giving them opportunity to work in the US