V roce 1993 federální vláda schválila federální zákon o obnovení náboženské svobody. Zákon měl chránit domorodé Američany v nebezpečí ztráty zaměstnání kvůli náboženským obřadům, které zahrnovaly nelegální drogu peyote. V roce 1997 Nejvyšší soud USA rozhodl, že Kongres překročil své meze, když schválil RFRA v roce 1993, a že zákon se vztahuje pouze na federální zákony, nikoli…
Přečtěte si víceZúžit rozhovor na tyto účastníky:
@2JDTKT85 let5Y
Yes, unless it gets any taxpayer money.
@2JGWPW45 let5Y
Yes do what u want. I just won't give them my business.
@2JCTBTJ5 let5Y
It depends on what that business is and whether or not that business gets any form of government subsidies. I don't want hospitals or doctors turning people away for any reason.
@2HZ5SZR5 let5Y
If your going to refuse work because you feel someone is living in sin (for being gay for example) then you have to refuse work for ALL sins that are against your religion. You shouldn't get to discriminate based on sexual orientation.
@2JD9K2N5 let5Y
If you are in business you should not allow religion, sex, color, etc. influence how you treat your customers. You are entitled to your beliefs and they are to theirs. If your beliefs are so strong that you want to deny service then you need to have a private business where only those who subscribe to your beliefs can be served. Limits your business...your choice...
@2JDD4MQ5 let5Y
Yes, as long as you are not providing a public service, like driving a taxi, medical care. If you are selling something that can easily be bought next door, then have at it.
@2JDTYFP5 let5Y
In certain circumstances, Yes. Doctors/hospitals should be able to refuse to perform abortions. Churches should not have to recognize same sex marriages.
@2JDWQDS5 let5Y
Privately owned businesses offering a non-essential (codified in law) product or service should be able to deny that product or service based on religious beliefs which they have demonstrably adhered (one could sue if they showed the business or it's owners have not applied their religious views uniformly or the religion is not recognized).
@2JDX7XN5 let5Y
Not if they are a public accommodation, accept public funding or are publically traded
@2JHV3ZD5 let5Y
yes, but they can't complain when their shop gets boycotted and they lose all business.
@ISIDEWITH12 měsíců12MO
Myslíte si, že by mělo být firmám dovoleno odmítnout poskytnutí služby na základě jejich náboženských přesvědčení, nebo by osobní přesvědčení měla zůstat oddělena od veřejného podnikání?
@ISIDEWITH12 měsíců12MO
Jak byste se cítili, kdyby se vaše důležitá víra neshodovala s právem - měla by osobní víra někdy převážit právní požadavky?
@ISIDEWITH12 měsíců12MO
Může být riziko v povolení náboženských svobodných zákonů vytvářet výjimky pro některé lidi, ale ne pro ostatní?
@ISIDEWITH12 měsíců12MO
V jakých způsobech by mohly být zákony o náboženské svobodě použity k ochraně jak náboženských praktik, tak práv menšinových komunit?
@ISIDEWITH12 měsíců12MO
Jak si myslíte, že by měla být v dnešní společnosti řešena rovnováha mezi ochranou náboženské víry a prevencí diskriminace?
@ISIDEWITH12 měsíců12MO
Myslíte si, že existuje rozdíl mezi ochranou náboženských praktik a povolením nábožensky motivované diskriminace na veřejných prostranstvích?
@ISIDEWITH12 měsíců12MO
Pokud by vám byla odepřena služba kvůli náboženským přesvědčením někoho jiného, jak byste se cítili ohledně jejich svobody tak činit?
@ISIDEWITH12 měsíců12MO
Měla by se vláda zapojit, když se střetávají náboženské přesvědčení a veřejné služby, nebo by mělo být toto rozhodnutí ponecháno na podnik a zákazníka?
@ISIDEWITH12 měsíců12MO
Myslíte si, že zákony o náboženské svobodě by měly být přizpůsobeny změnám společenských názorů, nebo by měly zůstat konzistentní v průběhu času?
@ISIDEWITH12 měsíců12MO
Jak si myslíte, že různé kulturní nebo náboženské skupiny mohou vnímat zákony o náboženské svobodě různými způsoby a jaké výzvy by to mohlo přinést?
@2JDYQR35 let5Y
Yes, you can deny service to whomever you choose, but I have the right to call you on it and not give you my money. Free market economies are like that.
@2JDNGJX5 let5Y
It's a personal issue. I would not want to patronize a business that has bigoted ideas
@2JHYTWJ5 let5Y
Yes, unless denying service will affect the health and/or safety of that customer.
@2JHN8DD5 let5Y
If a business wants to refuse revenue for any reason, that should be their choice. But when they go bankrupt due to the lost revenue, the government should not bail them out.
@2JDXT775 let5Y
A good business owner would not refuse any good paying customers
@2JHX88Y5 let5Y
As long as the business is not subsidized by the federal govt.
@2JH4ZVK5 let5Y
Private and not govt run businesses should have the right to deny service to anyone ... Period! It is their business & govt & courts should not get involved. Most will still serve a person because they cannot afford to turn away business ... So let those few who do not wish to serve a person for any reason, do so. I would not even want a person to serve me if I knew they had such hate and distain for me, so why would I insist upon them serving me out of principal.
@2JH3GNV5 let5Y
If you own your own business, you have the right to refuse service to anyone without reason...
@2JH4JBG5 let5Y
As long as the business discriminates based upon all old testament activities equally: Wearing mixed cloths, women talking in church, women must wear hats, only eating animals with cloven hoof, if your brother dies suddenly you must impregnate his wife, etc. In other words, they must discriminate equally.
@2JHGV9F5 let5Y
Yes, any business should be able to deny service for any reason. But they also then accept the consequences of the publicity that their decision generates
@2JHH7FN5 let5Y
if you're going to deny service to a group of people, then be honest and own it. make it public. "because of my religious beliefs i cannot offer services to homosexuals" for example. that way i won't even waste my time coming into your establishment and will simply go to someone who will offer me services
@2JHRFZZ5 let5Y
Only if the policy is displayed on the outside of the building. That way a costumer does not have to enter an establishment with the expectation of service only to be turned away.
@2JJ2K875 let5Y
i believe they should have the right to deny business but that doesn't make it the right thing to do.
@2JJ2M635 let5Y
Yes, as long as that stance is posted prominently on the premises